Anton+Barba+on+Tribal+Rights

If i am the judge in this case, I would also make Ms. Wilngal win the case. Not that i do not respect the old traditions of the tribal groups, but I think women should not be treated as mere possessions of a tribe that can be traded if in case there is a conflict between tribes. My first question to the tribe is why should women be traded? and If women are traded can men be traded also? if not why?

I think this case is complicated because in the old days men treat women as to be less superior than them but people today treat women equally. It is definitely a conflict between old rules and new rules. Since Ms. Wilngal chose the courts i believe that she should be given equal treatment as how men are treated and she should not be used by the tribes. Moreover, the case stated that Ms. Wilngal refused to go with the practice. With these in mind I think that the Ms. Wilngal has opposed the beliefs or traditions of the tribe therefore making her not a part of the tribe anymore.

The elders of the tribe should consider looking for another woman or think of other things that can be used to replace their loss. In my point of view, Ms. Wilngal chose not to be a part of the tribe anymore so the other tribe does not have the right to sue the clan of Ms. Wingal or Ms. Wingal herself.